A six-month randomized trial found no clear winner among balanced, lower-carbohydrate, and lower-fat plans for reducing weight or visceral fat. The practical takeaway is flexibility: several approaches may work modestly when they fit a person’s circumstances.
What changed
Researchers in Brazil randomized 141 adults with excess weight to three individualized, calorie-restricted diets or group nutrition counseling. Among 101 participants with six-month measurements, average weight loss was about 3%, and 30.7% lost at least 5% of their starting weight. Weight, waist size, and ultrasound-measured visceral fat improved over time, without significant differences among groups. Blood sugar, HbA1c, total cholesterol, and blood pressure also changed without a consistent macronutrient winner.
How strong is the evidence?
This was a registered human randomized trial, published November 16, 2026. Monthly follow-up, blinded fat measurements, and an active counseling comparison are strengths. The diets were prescribed rather than provided.
What remains uncertain
Twenty-nine percent of randomized participants lacked six-month visceral-fat data. The lower-carb and lower-fat groups drifted toward a balanced pattern, weakening the comparison. Weight loss was modest, follow-up lasted six months, and ultrasound fat thickness is a surrogate rather than a clinical outcome. Related results were reported previously, so this is an expanded analysis, not an entirely new experiment.
Why it matters
The study argues against treating one macronutrient split as universally best. Sustainability, food quality, and follow-up may matter more than a “low-fat” or “low-carb” label. See our Pantry & Kitchen guide and our brief on fat quality in type 2 diabetes.
Sources
European Journal of Clinical Nutrition: Six-month randomized trial of dietary interventions and abdominal fat (published November 16, 2026; NCT06320782).
Illustrative stock photo by Ella Olsson on Unsplash. The image does not show study participants, prescribed meals, or results.
